Choosing Bathroom Features for Your Dream Home: Showers, Tubs, or Both?

When looking for your new dream home, how do you decide which bathroom features are perfect for you and your home? Where do you start?

There are bathtubs, walk-in showers, and tub/shower combinations. Which bathrooms get which features? There are many things to consider when deciding which bathroom features will best fit your family’s needs and your home’s layout. Below are the pros and cons of each option to help you decide if a shower, tub, or both are a good option for your new home:

Bathtubs

Pros

• A Glamorous Look: A big, separate tub looks and feels very luxurious. Free-standing tubs have come such a long way and are now a piece of functional art. Today’s soaking tubs are as beautiful as they are relaxing.
• Rest and Relaxation: Soaking in a tub can be good for your health as it helps to relax your mind and muscles. Many tubs also have built-in jets, whirlpools, and spa-like features. Spa day can be every day!
• For the Children: Having a tub allows you to easily bathe small kids (and pets!) as it is wider and deeper than sinks.
• Resale Value: There is no need to put a tub in every bathroom, but there should be at least one in the house. This is crucial for resale value.

Cons

• Can Be Hard to Get In and Out: Tubs, especially very large ones, can be difficult for older people or those with injuries or disabilities to navigate.
• Lots of Water: Filling a bathtub uses significant water, which is not eco-friendly and can increase utility bills, even with energy-efficient fixtures.
• Lots of Space: A bathtub can dominate a floor plan. Skipping a large tub can make your bathroom feel more spacious.

Showers

Pros

• On Trend: Walk-in showers are highly popular in new homes. Builders are increasingly prioritizing larger shower stalls with ceramic tile surrounds, replacing tub-shower combos in some floor plans. Luxury features like built-in benches, rain shower heads, jets, and steam options are also in demand.
• Safe for Life: Curbless showers eliminate tripping hazards, making them ideal for aging in place. Add handle bars for extra safety.
• Eco-Friendly: Showers typically use less water than tubs, especially with high-efficiency showerheads.

Cons

• Cleaning and Maintenance: Glass shower doors require frequent upkeep to prevent mineral buildup and cloudiness.
• For the Children: Bathing babies and kids is easier in a tub, making showers less practical for families.
• No Spa Bath: Showers lack the immersive relaxation of a deep soak.

Best of Both Worlds

• Tub/Shower Combo: Ideal for smaller spaces or guest bathrooms, combining functionality without requiring extra room.
• Separate Tub and Shower: Perfect for larger bathrooms, like master suites, where space allows for both features.

Thinking Ahead

Your needs may change over time. If aging in place is a priority, prioritize safety with curbless showers or walk-in tubs. Many homeowners over 50 prefer walk-in showers over tub/shower combos for accessibility.

Final Considerations: Evaluate your floor plan’s space, how long you plan to live in the home, and any family accommodations. Create a bathroom that balances practicality with luxury—a space where you can relax, recharge, and enjoy the comforts of home.